Lot #: 144886

Asking Price: $2,999.00


Buy It Now

0 220
Track this lot?

Description

GROUNDBREAKING 'Blues' discovery: 7 May 1918 postmarked color picture postcard (Cenacle in Jerusalem) sent from JERUSALEM to MARSEILLE France with same day dated message in French; franked 5 milliemes for the period overseas postcard postage rate using a 5m overprinted frank (Ba #4) in ultramarine & tied by clear near-full strike of Army Post Office SZ 44 (JERUSALEM) postmark; tied by PALESTINE CENSORSHIP No. 2 handstamp. The discovery: this stamp exhibits the print characteristics of Transfer G plate position 101 (ink blob on upper left edge of "O" & drooping middle stroke of final "F" of "EEF" in bottom panel) with corresponding overprint characteristics for position 101 of overprint transfer C4 (indentation in ink on bottom stroke of "E" & partly missing shading of line in bottom left panel) - however the literature and even reproduced first-hand accounts of the production of the blues state that overprint transfer C4 belonged to printing control number D18C of the 2nd printing of the #4 issue of overprinted EEF stamps; the 1st printing of #4 on ultramarine sheets was produced on 26 Feb. 1918 and issued for use on 5 March, while the 2nd printing of which this postcard's frank belongs, was printed on 12 May and issued for use on the 13th - but here we see it in use already on May 7th. The postmark strike is clear in the critical areas, primarily the date - and 7 May is also borne out by the date of the written message, so there is no possibility that the postmark date may be 17 May. If this overprint type pre-dates the commonly believed date of production and issuance, how much earlier might it have been in use and more broadly is there any validity to the known dates of issue for any of the overprints at all?

Indeed, albeit pending further research by this cataloguer, there may be a general erronious methodology used in distinguishing between the overprinted #2 cobalt (lighter hue of blue than the ultramarine) and #4 ultramarine stamps, as this cataloger has noticed that the stamps claimed to be in cobalt blue actually appear identical to ultramarine - but are "confirmed" as being cobalt solely by the methodology of the supposed issuance date and usage period of that issue (by way of the postmark dates tying those franks) or by way of the overprint type (A1 on control B18A) said to be unique to that issue (and it may be that they are not in fact the #2 cobalt issue at all - see the final image in this display of 2 "cobalt" stamps from a sale by an AIEP certified dealer, and note the difference in their colors; the cobalt color is on the left). It should also be noted that as per research by Paulo Risi and Aladdin Adwan (BAPIP 166 of Nov. 2012) the entire blues issue was printed on large 480 stamp sheets composed of 4x 120 stamp panes, each being one of the 4 known transfers (B, D, F, G) and each transfer with its overprint: this leaves open the possibility, for example, that ultramarine stamps were overprinted by type A1, leading catalogers to erroniously believe that these are "cobalt" stamps. Ben-Arieh certificate enclosed.