Description
UNIQUE World War II DISPATCHED & RETURNED wartime civilian mail to Nazi Germany: Sept-Oct 1939 era postmarked cover on Jerusalem 'Etz Hayim Yeshiva' imprinted postal stationary (marked "return postage guaranteed"), sent from JERUSALEM to SILUTE "Lithuania"; likely franked 15 mils (Ba #108) now missing, for overseas surface mail & tied by a strike of the single-circle canceller of the sorting office (i.e. the cover was deposted un-postmarked into a letter box and processed later when the box was emptied).
As of 23 March 1939 the locale became part of German-annexed Memelland (not Lithuania) and so part of the Third Reich - hence the cover was now processed by the military censor in Konigsberg, tied by its handstamp "Auslandsbriefprüfstelle | Königsberg (Pr)" and released for ongoing transmission when approved, tied by "Von der Wehrmacht zugelassen" instructional marking handstamp; the cover was backstamped 30 Oct 1939 KONIGSBURG transit & next day HEYDEKRUG (Silute) arrival - but the address was found to be unknown.
The cover was affixed on the back with a German/French 'Unknown' address label, manuscript marked in German "return 31/10" in blue crayon on the front & RETURNED TO SENDER in spite of WWII - 2 months after the outbreak of the war.
The cover was received back at HAIFA (i.e. by sea, not rail) where it was opened & resealed by Sacher-unlisted H. No. 9 Q9a red/pink label and tied by double-framed rectangle H9 censor handstamp (Sach-Q21 - known used in April 1940) & tied by local instructional marking handstamps "Return To" + " Undelivered For the Reason Stated on the Cover" (Sach L10/L12). Ironically there is no indication of the return-fee being charged or collected. Slit open at bottom; frayed edges.
Of note: Palestine officially suspended all mail service to and from Germany on 6 Sept. 1939; as the cover lacks outgoing censor marks, the cover was likely sent not only prior to the 6th, but also prior to September 1st, when WWII broke out and censorship began in Palestine. What may have facilitated the cover's onward transmission may have been the sender's unusual insistance on addressing the locale as "Lithuania" and not "Germany" - as such not affected by any postal suspensions affecting "Germany", but clearly processed by Germany once the war began, as evidenced by the wartime censor markings.
The extraordinary element of this cover is that the officially used reason for the return of the letter was not the state of suspended service between Germany and Palestine, but rather due to a procedural instance of the mail being undeliverable for technical reasons, and neither Germany or Palestine used the "no service" markings that were in use at this time to process the cover.
A study of Universal Postal Union convention history, of which both countries were members, does not shed much light on relations between beligerents in wartime (i.e. the 1939 Convention): a) adherence to the convention is voluntary and a violation of the principle of "liberty of transit" (articles 26/80) by one country can be reciprocated by a suspension of postal service with that country by the violated country, and "suspended service" mail between the two countries from the war period is known; b) the US State Department noted in 1946 that "the Union continued to operate as usual during the war, although postal service between many countries necessarily was curtailed or suspended" (ref Department of State, publication 2699 p.301-2 cited in Stuart Hull MacIntyre, 1958); c) and Palestine published in February 1942 (Official Gazette #1176) its adherence to the 1939 UPU convention. In conclusion the return & acceptance of this mail for non-political reasons cannot be unequivocally relegated to adherence to the UPU convention because "suspended service" mail with wartime Germany is known, but it's equally unlikely that this cover was returned to a belligerent by mistake. Likely, there may have been an inconsistent policy regarding the handling of such mail. Regardless, very rare postal handling - possibly unique in WWII Palestine postal history. Well documented postal history gem & highly ironic as from Jewish religious institute with Hebrew and Torah-crown device on cover - elements resticted by wartime German censorship regulations.